Welcome to Pizza Guy
Pizza Guy, located at 323 N Wales Rd, Wisconsin, is a hidden gem for pizza lovers. Renowned for its delicious hand-tossed crust and flavorful sauces, the menu showcases standout options like BBQ chicken and sausage/mushroom pizzas. Customers rave about the ooey-gooey cheese-filled breadsticks and crave-worthy jalapeño poppers. The emphasis on quality ingredients sets Pizza Guy apart, making it a preferred choice over larger chains. Additionally, the rewarding mobile program adds value, ensuring loyal patrons benefit on future visits. With a cozy atmosphere and a promise of consistency, Pizza Guy is a must-visit for anyone seeking exceptional pizza and comfort food.
Pizza Guy: Reviews & Ratings
First time here and it was well worth it. Pizza (BBQ chicken and Sausage/mush) were delicious. Great tasting hand tossed crust, flavorful sauce and the right amount of toppings and cheese. We also had some cheese bread which was good too. They also have a reward system via mobile phone to get some credits and discounts on future purchases. 1 1 point & 25/credit at 250 points. We will certainly be back and wish we hadn’t taken so long to finally try it after driving by for so many years. I think I’ve found our “Go To” pizza place!
Pizza is so much better than dominoes and Pizza hut. The jalapeno poppers and cheese sticks are to die for! The best food I've had in a long rime!
First time trying this place. Loved it! Got the cheese filled breadsticks and a sausage, pepperoni and mushroom pizza hand tossed. Best cheese sticks! Loaded with cheese that oozed out after taking a bite. Liked the pizza sauce taste and it was well balanced with the cheese and toppings.
The cheese sticks are worth the hype! My husband LOVED them- I like them because they’re basically giant mozzarella sticks (nothing wrong with that!). The pizza was very good and good quality. A little on the pricier side but local and convenient so worth it. Overall, good pizza and great cheese sticks. Will be trying their thin crust next time!
So glad I took the time to stop in this small restaurant! One of the best pizza places in SE Wisconsin! Quality cheese and ingredients are the first thing that I noticed on my first visit. Consistency is what keeps me coming back!
Ordered a pizza and garden salad to go tonight & they are both amazing!! I walked in and was greeted in a friendly & prompt manner!! Our cauliflour crust pizza is delicious, along with the huge fresh salad. Kuddos to the pizza maker!! The salad is loaded with tomatoes, mushrooms, black olives, green pepper, & onions! Can't wait to go back real soon!! Lastly, their customer service is over the top...after I placed my order over the phone I received a call back from the young man just to go over my order to make sure everything is right (I really appreciated that)!!
Got some parbakes pizza to go today. First time trying this place, and my wife and I were very surprised at how good it is. We are currently on a mission to try different pizza places in our area (Sullivan) to see which is the best, and this one is definitely a contender! The mac cheesesticks are HUGE!!! 1 is almost enough for 2 people.
My new favorite pizza in the Lake Country Area! We got an extra thick meatball and basil pizza and everything about it was great. I loved the thickness and consistency of the crust. The basil was fresh tasting and smelled so good. And the meatballs were tender and tasty. We will definitely be ordering from Pizza Guy again in the near future.
Location
-
323 N Wales Rd, Wales, WI 53183, United States Hotline: +1 262-968-4900
Welcome to the world of Pizza Guy, a hidden gem located at 323 N Wales Rd, Wales, WI 53183. This charming pizzeria has quickly made a name for itself, delighting customers with its hand-tossed crusts, rich sauces, and delectable toppings. As a food reviewer, I can assure you that a visit to Pizza Guy is well worth your time.
Customer reviews echo a common sentiment: the pizza here is nothing short of exceptional. Take S. M. (Smacks) for instance, who raved about the BBQ chicken and sausage/mushroom pizzas. The hand-tossed crust, he noted, provided a perfect foundation for the flavors, balanced expertly with just the right amount of savory toppings and cheese. It's this attention to detail that turns first-time visitors into loyal regulars.
The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it the perfect spot for families and friends to gather. The menu doesn't stop at pizza; their cheese bread is also a standout, a delightful addition that complements the main event. \"The cheese sticks are worth the hype!\" declared Nicole Wittkopp, emphasizing the cheesy goodness that has patrons returning for more.
For those who crave variety, Pizza Guy presents a stellar lineup of appetizers, including jalapeno poppers and cheese sticks that have received high praise from customers like Theresa Maddox, who noted they are \"to die for!\" These offerings ensure that the lunch or dinner experience goes beyond just pizza, transforming it into a culinary feast.
One of the highlights of this establishment is not just the food, but the customer-centric approach they adopt. With a reward system via mobile phone, patrons are encouraged to earn credits and discounts on future purchases. Matthew Allan's experience speaks to the quality and consistency that keep him coming back—something every foodie strives to find.
The prices are a tad higher than a typical pizza chain, but as Nick Quarne mentioned, the quality of cheese and ingredients makes each bite worthwhile. You get what you pay for, and at Pizza Guy, you truly enjoy every penny spent.
In summary, Pizza Guy is more than just a pizza place; it’s an experience defined by quality, flavor, and community. Whether you're craving a classic sausage and pepperoni or looking to try their thin crust on your next visit, this pizzeria promises a satisfying meal that you won’t soon forget. Don't wait too long to experience it for yourself!